Which situation exemplifies simple affray?

Simple affray occurs when two or more individuals engage in a violent confrontation, causing a disturbance in public places that can alarm or frighten bystanders. In this context, a fight in a public park with bystanders clearly demonstrates the elements of simple affray. The presence of bystanders, the public setting, and the violent nature of the encounter contribute to the disruption of public peace, fulfilling the criteria for affray.

In contrast, while a loud argument between friends might be disruptive, it does not involve physical violence and therefore does not meet the definition of affray. An argument escalating in a private room is similarly nonpublic, focusing on the lack of concern for public order. A game that turns aggressive among a group may involve some level of conflict but lacks the necessary violent confrontation and public nature associated with affray. Thus, the situation that best illustrates simple affray is the one that involves a physical fight in a public space with bystanders witnessing the event.